A website doesn’t go off like yoghurt, but it does age. Sometimes fixing it is enough; sometimes patching it costs more than starting over. These are the signs that, after eleven years of working on WordPress sites, tell me it’s time for a new one, with a way to check each of them yourself.
1. It can no longer be updated
Old versions of WordPress or PHP, themes abandoned by their authors, plugins that break something with every update. It’s the most common case and the riskiest: a site that can’t be updated is easier to hack.
How to check: in your WordPress dashboard go to Tools, then Site Health. If you see warnings about outdated PHP or themes and plugins that haven’t been updated in years, you have a problem. If the theme hasn’t had an update for a long time, it’s unlikely to get one in future.
2. It’s awkward on a phone
Most visits now come from smartphones. If people have to zoom in to read, the buttons are tiny or the menu won’t open properly, you’re losing enquiries without knowing it. Google also judges websites mainly on how they work on mobile.
How to check: try doing the three things a customer needs to do on your phone, such as finding a service, reading your opening hours and contacting you. If it’s hard work for you, it’s hard work for them.
3. It’s slow
If the site takes many seconds to load, some people leave before they see it. The usual culprits are heavy themes, outdated page builders, huge images and dozens of plugins piled up over the years.
How to check: enter your address in Google’s PageSpeed Insights and look at the mobile result. If the scores are low and the suggestions point to the theme or page builder, slimming it down may not be enough.
4. You can’t edit it yourself
If you have to call someone to change your opening hours, add an event or swap a photo, the site is working against you. A good website can be updated in minutes by the people who use it every day.
How to check: think of the last change you wanted to make and didn’t. If the answer is “too many”, the problem isn’t you, it’s how the site was built.
5. It no longer represents you
New services, a new logo, a business that has grown, customers different from five years ago. Your website should tell people who you are today. If you send the link with a touch of embarrassment, or avoid sending it at all, that’s a clear sign.
How to check: read your home page as if you were a new customer. Can you tell within seconds what you do, who for, and how to get in touch?
One more sign: the rules have changed
Privacy, cookie and accessibility rules have changed in recent years. Since 28 June 2025, for example, the European Accessibility Act has required certain digital services, such as online shops, to meet accessibility standards. Microenterprises providing services are exempt, but a website everyone can use is worth having anyway. If your site was built before these rules, it should at least be checked.
Fix or rebuild: how to decide
Fix it when the foundations are sound: the theme is maintained, the structure works and the problems are specific, such as a plugin to replace, images to optimise or a few pages to rewrite.
Rebuild it when the problems are structural: an abandoned theme, a heavy page builder, versions that can’t be updated, content that needs rethinking. In these cases every fix is a patch, and the patches end up costing more than a new site.
A new website doesn’t mean losing what you’ve built. Pages already found on Google can be kept or redirected, good content can be reused, and you start from a base that will last for years.
Not sure?
With a fixed-price check-up I look at your website and tell you in writing whether it’s worth fixing or rebuilding, and what each option would cost. If fixing it makes more sense, I’ll say so, even if it means less work for me. You’ll find the details under WordPress support; if you’d rather start afresh, have a look at websites for professionals and small businesses and some recent work. Or book a 20-minute call and we’ll talk it through.
